Making History • HIST 1105 • Week 8.1

The Big Picture in 6 Parts

  • 1: Who chose the facts · Weeks 1, 3, 4, 6, 7
  • 2: What history is for · Weeks 2–4, 7
  • 3: The shape of the story · Weeks 2, 5
  • 4: Standards of evidence · Weeks 3, 4, 6
  • 5: What moves history · Weeks 5–6
  • 6: Progress as an idea · Weeks 3–4

Part one · Weeks 1, 3, 4, 6, 7

Somebody chose the facts, often before any historian arrived

Every history is a selection. Much of it was made before the historian started: in who kept records, what seemed worth a line, and who paid for the archive.

Who chose the facts · 1 / 4 · Carr, Week 1

Carr: the historian decides which facts get the floor

An aquatint of cavalry with raised sabres riding into a packed crowd under banners reading Universal Suffrage

“The facts speak only when the historian calls on them.” Carr, What Is History?, p. 11

Caesar crossing the Rubicon is a historical fact; millions of others crossing it interest “nobody at all.” This print of Peterloo names Henry Hunt and nobody in the crowd.

Richard Carlile, To Henry Hunt, Esq., 1819 · St Peter’s Field, Manchester, where some sixty thousand gathered · photograph by APK, CC BY 4.0 · cropped

Who chose the facts · 2 / 4 · the Chronicle, Week 3

Clergy chose which years got a line

A manuscript page of the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle: year headings down the left margin, several with no entry after them

On this page the years 711, 712 and 713 are a heading and a number. Nothing happened to the people who counted, of a kind that counted.

For centuries after Rome fell, clergy were “almost all of the authors of history” in the west (Popkin, p. 41).

Anglo-Saxon Chronicle MS D, fol. 20r · British Library, Cotton MS Tiberius B.iv · public domain

Who chose the facts · 3 / 4 · Popkin, Week 4

States paid for the new professional history

An engraving of a professor lecturing from a raised desk to a packed hall of students

“The increasingly professionalized scholarly history of the nineteenth century was heavily dependent on national governments for support.” Popkin, p. 85

Berlin’s university was founded in 1810 as part of a program to promote German national identity (p. 79). Women “remained almost entirely excluded” from the seminars (p. 94).

Heinrich von Treitschke lecturing in Berlin, 1879 · contemporary engraving, artist unrecorded · public domain

Who chose the facts · 4 / 4 · Thompson and Ginzburg

Ordinary people reach us through those who policed them

A hand-colored etching of a man in a woman's blue spotted dress striding forward with a club, a burning mill behind him

Thompson reads spy reports and trials against the grain. Ginzburg’s miller can be heard only because the Inquisition wrote down his answers.

This print of “General Ludd” says it was “Drawn from Life by an Officer.”

The Leader of the Luddites, May 1812 · Working Class Movement Library · public domain

Part one · discussion

Who got the floor


Carr says the facts speak only when the historian calls on them. Pick a writer from the course and name something they gave the floor to that earlier history had left out.

Part two · Weeks 2–4, 7

Every writer says what history is for

Nearly every writer in the course gives the past a job; Ranke’s is to refuse the others. The job decides what is worth telling.

What history is for · 1 / 4 · Herodotus, Week 2

Herodotus’s job is remembering great deeds, so foreigners’ deeds go in too

A marble portrait bust of a bearded man

“that the memory of the past may not be blotted out from among men by time, and that great and marvellous deeds done by Greeks and foreigners … may not lack renown” Herodotus, Histories 1.1 (Godley trans.)

His word for the work, istoria, means inquiry (Popkin, p. 28). The face is a reconstruction, carved some six centuries after he died.

Roman portrait bust of Herodotus, 2nd c. CE · Metropolitan Museum of Art, 91.8 · CC0

What history is for · 2 / 4 · Livy and Bede, Weeks 2–3

Livy and Bede, centuries apart, want history to give examples to imitate

A Renaissance painting of a classical square: at the center a man stands over a woman's body raising a sword to a crowd of soldiers

“choose for yourself and for your own state what to imitate” Livy, Ab Urbe Condita, Preface (Foster trans.)

Bede’s preface of 731 asks readers to imitate the good and shun the wrong. So the stories that get told are lessons, like Livy’s Lucretia.

Sandro Botticelli, The Story of Lucretia, c. 1500–01: Livy’s exemplary death, ending the monarchy · Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum · public domain

What history is for · 3 / 4 · Machiavelli, Week 3

Machiavelli wants history to teach a ruler how to keep the state

A Renaissance portrait of a thin man in black with a faint smile

“A wise man ought always to follow the paths beaten by great men, and to imitate those who have been supreme” The Prince, ch. 6 (Marriott trans.)

Livy and Bede say imitate too, and mean virtue. Machiavelli means technique, so he judges a cruelty by its timing, not its justice.

Niccolò Machiavelli, by Santi di Tito · Palazzo Vecchio, Florence · public domain

What history is for · 4 / 4 · Ranke, Ginzburg, Weeks 4, 7

Change the job, change the history

A dim photograph of a room walled with bookshelves, papers stacked in front, an old man barely visible at a desk

Read as Ranke read his sources, for what officials did and decided, an inquisition record gives a procedure carried out.

Ginzburg read it for what the miller believed, and got a cosmos.

Leopold von Ranke in his library, early 1880s · Ranke Papers, Syracuse University · public domain

Part two · discussion

What the past is for


Pick two writers from the course who want different things from history. What does each want, and why could the same source give them two different histories?

Part three · Weeks 2, 5

The shape of the story is part of the argument

Before any method, each writer chose a form, and the form argues things the facts cannot argue on their own.

The shape of the story · 1 / 4 · Herodotus, Week 2

Herodotus shapes Croesus’s fall as a parable

A red-figure Greek vase: a bearded king sits enthroned on a stacked pyre holding a dish, while a young man tends the fire below

A warning ignored, an ambiguous oracle, pride, reversal, recognition on the pyre.

The scene was painted about sixty years before Herodotus wrote, so his audience knew the story. The shaping is his, and the moral lives in it.

Croesus on the pyre, Attic red-figure amphora by Myson, c. 500–490 BCE · Louvre G 197 · photo Bibi Saint-Pol · public domain

The shape of the story · 2 / 4 · Thucydides, Week 2

Thucydides puts the argument in speeches he composed himself

A map of the Aegean in 431 BCE, Athens and its subject allies shaded, with small neutral islands among them

“to make the speakers say what, in my opinion, was called for by each situation” Thucydides 1.22, quoted in Popkin, p. 30

At Melos “the strong do what they can and the weak suffer what they must” (5.89, Crawley trans.). The dialogue stages justice against power without saying which he backs.

The Athenian Empire on the eve of the Peloponnesian War, 431 BCE · Marsyas, derivative by Once in a Blue Moon · CC BY-SA 3.0

The shape of the story · 3 / 4 · Sima Qian, Week 2

Sima Qian makes an argument with his table of contents

A Chinese painted portrait of a seated ruler in red robes

Xiang Yu lost, and never ruled a unified empire. Sima Qian files him in the basic annals, the section for legitimate sovereigns.

He was still being painted as a king two thousand years later.

Xiang Wang (Xiang Yu), from Portraits of Famous Men, 19th–early 20th c. · Philadelphia Museum of Art · public domain

The shape of the story · 4 / 4 · Braudel, Week 5

For Braudel, even telling events in order is an argument

A hand-colored sea chart of the Mediterranean, coastlines and ports drawn in detail, crossed by straight bearing lines

“narrative history is not an objective method, still less the supreme objective method, but is itself a philosophy of history” Braudel, 1949 preface, On History, p. 4

His Mediterranean puts events last. A chart like this records the sea as a set of routes, close to what he means by a structure.

Chart of the Mediterranean and north-east Atlantic, Paolo Forlani after Diogo Homem, Venice, 1569 · National Maritime Museum, Greenwich · public domain · cropped

Part three · discussion

A neutral form


Is a footnoted, neutral-sounding history a form too? What does it argue by its shape?

Part four · Weeks 3, 4, 6

Each standard of evidence in the course rests on a belief about the world

Every period in the course had rules for proof. They differ less in rigour than in what each assumed could happen.

Standards of evidence · 1 / 4 · Bede, Week 3

Bede assumes God acts, so miracles are evidence

A medieval manuscript page in a dense Latin hand, with lines of Old English added in the lower margin

“For it was impossible that the martyr, who had left no water remaining in the river, should desire it on the top of the hill, unless he thought it fitting.” Bede, Ecclesiastical History I.7

The cures at Alban’s shrine “cease not to this day”: evidence anyone could go and check.

Bede, Ecclesiastical History IV.24, where he says his Latin gives “the sense but not the order” of Cædmon’s song · Bodleian Libraries, MS Hatton 43, fol. 129r · CC BY-SA 4.0

Standards of evidence · 2 / 4 · al-Biruni, Week 3

Al-Biruni assumes nature keeps its laws

An illustrated Persian manuscript page showing a robed figure, with text above and below

“No one will deny that in questions of historic authenticity hearsay does not equal eyewitness” al-Biruni, Kitab al-Hind, preface (Sachau trans.)

Bede’s drying river would be screened out before he asked who told it. The rest he chases back to “the originator of the story,” alert to five kinds of liar.

al-Biruni, al-Āthār al-bāqiya, fol. 230, the prophet Bihāfrīd, a later illustrated copy · Bibliothèque nationale de France · public domain

Standards of evidence · 3 / 4 · Ranke, Week 4

Ranke assumes the truth is in the papers of people who were there

A printed German page in Fraktur type, the preface of Ranke's first book

“The basis of the present work, the sources of its material, are memoirs, diaries, letters, ambassadors’ reports, and original accounts of eyewitnesses … These sources will be noted on every page.” Ranke, 1824 introduction

In his seminar, students attacked one another’s citations. The method catches a misread document, and rarely an assumption the whole room shares.

Ranke, Geschichten der romanischen und germanischen Völker (1824), preface, p. VI · Internet Archive · public domain · cropped

Standards of evidence · 4 / 4 · Vansina, Week 6

Vansina drops the assumption that evidence has to be written

“A tradition should be seen as a series of successive historical documents all lost except for the last one and usually interpreted by every link in the chain of transmission.” Vansina, Oral Tradition as History, p. 29

Islamic scholars had judged hadith by their chains of transmission for centuries (p. 30). Vansina keeps Ranke’s rule, a link back to an observer.

Part four · discussion

What the method misses


Ranke says his book will “only” show what actually happened. Name one judgment that gets into his history anyway.

Part five · Weeks 5–6

Each answer to what moves history comes with a scale

The writers disagree about what causes change, and each answer brings a scale that decides what it can see.

What moves history · 1 / 4 · Marx, Week 5

For Marx, how people produce drives history, at the scale of whole classes

A watercolor of a green hillside with goats and figures at rest, a horizon of mill chimneys in a golden haze

“Men make their own history, but they do not make it just as they please” The Eighteenth Brumaire, quoted in Green and Troup, p. 36

The Manifesto called capitalism’s fall “equally inevitable.” Green and Troup see a paradox: change still depends on “the consciousness and actions of men and women” (p. 36).

William Wyld, Manchester from Kersal Moor, 1852 · Royal Collection · public domain

What moves history · 2 / 4 · Braudel, Week 5

For Braudel, slow structures drive history, at the scale of centuries

An oil painting of a sea crowded edge to edge with war galleys under banners and gunsmoke

“a surface disturbance, the waves stirred up by the powerful movement of tides” 1949 preface, On History, p. 3

Lepanto killed tens of thousands in an afternoon in 1571. The Ottomans rebuilt their fleet, and Venice made its peace in 1573.

The Battle of Lepanto, 7 October 1571 · unknown painter, late 16th c. · National Maritime Museum, Greenwich · public domain

What moves history · 3 / 4 · Thompson, Week 6

For Thompson, class is made in ordinary lives

A stipple engraving of an elderly woman seated in a frilled bonnet, books at her elbow

“The working class did not rise like the sun at an appointed time. It was present at its own making.” Thompson, p. 9

He keeps the people history wrote off, down to “the deluded follower of Joanna Southcott” (p. 12), a prophetess with thousands of followers.

Joanna Southcott, stipple engraving published by John Bell, 2 October 1814 · KU Leuven print collection · public domain · cropped

What moves history · 4 / 4 · Scott, Week 6

Scott adds gender, which works at every scale, even where no women are

An oil painting of a gilded hall: two dozen men in uniforms, sashes and frock coats around a long table

“High politics itself is a gendered concept, for it establishes its crucial importance and public power … precisely in its exclusion of women from its work.” Scott, p. 1073

Anton von Werner, Der Kongreß zu Berlin, closing session, 13 July 1878; painted 1892 · Deutsches Historisches Museum · public domain

Part five · discussion

Choosing a scale


Does the scale a historian works at follow from what they think history is for, or the other way round?

Part six · Weeks 3–4

Progress was an idea with its own history

The belief that history improves was argued for in the eighteenth century and contested at once. Histories of history long told the same story about themselves.

Progress as an idea · 1 / 4 · Voltaire, Week 4

Voltaire ranks the ages of history by one standard, taste

A painting of an elegant salon crowded with seated men and women listening to a reading

“Whosoever thinks, or, what is still more rare, whosoever has taste, will find but four ages in the history of the world. These four happy ages are those in which the arts were carried to perfection.” Age of Louis XIV, p. 5

The fourth, Louis XIV’s, ended when he was twenty: “Europe is indebted for its politeness and spirit of society to the court of Louis XIV” (pp. 7–8).

A reading of Voltaire’s L’Orphelin de la Chine in Madame Geoffrin’s salon, Paris, 1755 · Lemonnier, painted 1812, Château de Malmaison · public domain

Progress as an idea · 2 / 4 · Herder, Week 4

Herder, Kant’s former student, refused one standard for every people

A painted portrait of a man in a dark coat and white cravat

“[Herder] objected to the idea of measuring the distinctive cultures of different nations according to a universal standard of civilization derived from the experience of Western Europe.” Popkin, p. 68

By making the language-defined nation the unit of society, Herder “anticipated the strongly nationalist character of most European history-writing in the nineteenth century” (Popkin, p. 68).

Johann Gottfried Herder, by Anton Graff, 1785 · public domain

Progress as an idea · 3 / 4 · Ranke, Week 4

Ranke refused to rank epochs by progress, and still ranked peoples

A painted portrait of an old man with white hair, two decorations on his chest

“every epoch is immediate to God, and … its value consists, not in what follows it, but in its own existence” Ranke, 1854 lectures

Treating earlier generations as “only porters for the following generations” was “a divine injustice.” The same lecture calls Asia’s history “retrogressive.”

Leopold von Ranke, by Adolf Jebens, 1875 · public domain

Progress as an idea · 4 / 4 · Acton, Week 3

Historians long told their own past as progress: Acton wrote the medieval ones off

A photograph of a bearded man in a dark coat, seated

“careless and impatient of older fact. They became content to be deceived, to live in a twilight of fiction.” Acton, 1895, quoted in Popkin, pp. 40–41, who notes he allowed them “good writers of contemporary narrative”

Later scholars, Popkin says, saw a different purpose rather than a failure: to present “truths that would convince their readers of appropriate moral and religious lessons” (p. 41).

John Dalberg-Acton, 1st Baron Acton · Allen & Co., before 1902 · public domain

Part six · discussion

Progress or accumulation


Each turn on the syllabus fixed something. What did each one give up, and do the trades add up to progress?

The take home

You cannot measure progress until you say what history is for

On progress

Tests of sources were sharpened and spread (al-Biruni’s screen, Ranke’s footnote) and the range of evidence widened: oral tradition, the losers, gender. Carr’s caution holds: “an infinity of meanings, none any more right than any other” amounts to no meaning at all (p. 26).

On purpose

The choice of purpose shapes much of a history before the research begins. A defensible one can probably be stated openly, checked by someone who disagrees, and honest about its blind spots.

Next · Week 9, after the break

Many national traditions were invented, and recently

Nations feel ancient. Hobsbawm argues that many of their traditions were invented, often deliberately; Anderson calls nations imagined, not faked. Compare Kant’s plan nobody alive could see, in Week 4.1.